The Ultimate List of Cursed Monkey's Paw Wishes: Be Careful What You Ask For

The Ultimate List of Cursed Monkey's Paw Wishes: Be Careful What You Ask For

### Keyword Analysis:

  • Keyword: "monkeys paw wishes"
  • Occasion: This isn't a traditional occasion. It's a conceptual, literary exercise based on W. W. Jacobs' famous short story. The "occasion" is the hypothetical act of making a wish on a cursed object, exploring themes of irony, unintended consequences, and hubris. It's an occasion for dark humor, creative thinking, and cautionary storytelling.
  • Tone: The tone is inherently dark, ironic, witty, and cautionary. It can range from gallows humor and petty schadenfreude to genuinely horrifying cosmic irony. It is clever and macabre, never sincere or straightforwardly positive.
  • Recipient: The "recipient" of this article is someone fascinated by this concept—a fan of horror, dark fantasy, literature, or someone who enjoys creative "what if" scenarios. They are looking for inspiration for stories, role-playing games, or simply for the intellectual fun of crafting a perfectly flawed wish.

### Invented Categories:

Based on this analysis, I have invented the following 6 creative and relevant categories:

1. The Classic Catastrophe: Wishes That Sound Too Good to Be True

2. The Rules Lawyer's Gambit: Hyper-Specific Wishes to Outsmart the Paw

3. Darkly Comedic & Petty Desires: When You Just Want a Little Chaos

4. Cursed Connections: Wishes for Love, Lust, and Loneliness

5. The Price of Power: Wishes for Fame, Fortune, and a Terrible Fallout

6. The "Selfless" Sacrifice: Altruistic Wishes with a Sinister Silver Lining


The flickering candlelight catches the strange, mummified paw. Three wishes, they said. A chance to bend reality to your will. But as anyone familiar with the chilling tale by W. W. Jacobs knows, the Monkey's Paw grants wishes with a cruel and devastating irony. It's a masterclass in unintended consequences, a supernatural force that twists your words into a waking nightmare. The desire to make a wish, to fix a problem or fulfill a dream, is deeply human. The morbid fun of the Monkey's Paw is imagining how that very human desire could go horribly, horribly wrong.

Whether you're a writer looking for story prompts, a dungeon master crafting a new cursed item, or just a fan of dark humor exploring the limits of language, this list is for you. We’ve gathered a comprehensive collection of Monkey's Paw wishes, broken down by the wisher’s intent and their inevitable, tragic downfall. Hold the paw tight, take a deep breath, and let's explore what happens when your greatest wish becomes your greatest regret.

The Classic Catastrophe: Wishes That Sound Too Good to Be True

The Classic Catastrophe: Wishes That Sound Too Good to Be True

These are the foundational wishes—broad, simple desires with devastatingly direct and horrifying consequences. They are the epitome of "be careful what you wish for."

1. I wish for £200 to pay off my mortgage. (The classic. The money arrives as compensation for the tragic death of a loved one.)

2. I wish for my youth back. (You are reverted to infancy, with the mind and physical limitations of a baby, unable to care for yourself.)

3. I wish to know when I will die. (A piece of paper appears with today's date and the current time on it.)

4. I wish my failing business was successful. (Your competitor's factory burns down in a mysterious fire, and you receive all their clients—and the attention of a dogged arson investigator.)

5. I wish I could fly. (You grow hideous, leathery wings, and are hunted as a monster or captured for scientific study.)

6. I wish I never had to work again. (You are in a terrible accident that leaves you a quadriplegic, "cared for" for the rest of your life.)

7. I wish my family and I were safe from all harm. (You are all placed into a permanent, unresponsive coma—perfectly safe, perfectly unaware.)

8. I wish for a delicious, hot meal. (It appears before you, but it's the last meal of a death row inmate who was just executed.)

The Rules Lawyer's Gambit: Hyper-Specific Wishes to Outsmart the Paw

The Rules Lawyer's Gambit: Hyper-Specific Wishes to Outsmart the Paw

For the clever wisher who thinks they can outsmart a cosmic curse with semantics. The paw always finds the loophole in your loophole.

1. I wish for a winning lottery ticket, number 12-34-45-56-67, for this Saturday's Powerball drawing, to appear in my hand, with no negative physical, mental, or emotional consequences to me, my family, or my friends. (The ticket appears. You are so excited that you trip, fall, and enter a coma, waking up months after the ticket has expired.)

2. I wish for the ability to speak and understand every language on Earth, fluently and without accent. (You gain the knowledge, but lose the ability to speak or comprehend your native tongue, alienating you from everyone you've ever known.)

3. I wish for a bank account in my name with a balance of ten million US dollars, legally obtained and fully taxed. (The money was legally obtained by a brutal dictator who has now framed you for their crimes to escape justice. The money is yours, but you're now an international fugitive.)

4. I wish to be in peak physical condition, with the health of a 25-year-old Olympic athlete, for the rest of my natural life. (Your body is perfect, but you are now a carrier for a new, asymptomatic plague that is lethal to everyone you come into contact with.)

5. I wish my rude boss would recognize my value and treat me with the professional respect I deserve. (He suffers a massive stroke. In his debilitated state, he can only gaze at you with what looks like respect, but is actually a desperate, locked-in plea for help.)

6. I wish for a perfectly faithful, loving, and attractive partner who is my soulmate in every way. (They appear, and they are perfect. Unfortunately, they are already happily married to someone else, and you must live with the knowledge that you can never be together.)

7. I wish this paw would grant this wish exactly as I intend it in my mind, without any ironic twists or negative side effects. (The paw shrivels into dust, its power expended on the meta-paradox of the wish, granting you absolutely nothing.)

Darkly Comedic & Petty Desires: When You Just Want a Little Chaos

Darkly Comedic & Petty Desires: When You Just Want a Little Chaos

Sometimes you don't want a million dollars, you just want your neighbor to turn their music down. The paw is happy to oblige, with maximum collateral damage.

1. I wish my neighbor's incessantly barking dog would be quiet. (The dog is quiet because your neighbor has been practicing amateur taxidermy.)

2. I wish I never had to wait in traffic again. (Your car is now possessed and gleefully drives on the sidewalk and through buildings to avoid traffic jams.)

3. I wish my Wi-Fi was always fast and reliable. (It is. Because it now leeches bandwidth so powerfully that it creates a 10-block internet blackout zone around your house, making you the most hated person in your neighborhood.)

4. I wish I could find a parking spot right in front of my destination, every single time. (You do. Usually because the previous car was just towed, exploded, or was part of a crime scene.)

5. I wish my annoying coworker would quit. (They do, because they won the lottery. They spend the rest of their days posting travel photos while you toil away.)

6. I wish all the mosquitos in the world would just die. (They do, causing the collapse of multiple ecosystems and leading to a world overrun with the spiders and frogs that used to eat them.)

7. I wish this terrible coffee was a delicious, gourmet latte. (The cup instantly transmutes into a scalding hot, fragile porcelain latte cup that shatters in your hands, giving you second-degree burns.)

Cursed Connections: Wishes for Love, Lust, and Loneliness

Cursed Connections: Wishes for Love, Lust, and Loneliness

Matters of the heart are fertile ground for the paw's cruelest twists.

1. I wish my ex would realize what they lost and come crawling back. (They come back, but as a shambling, reanimated corpse, clawing at your door and moaning your name.)

2. I wish the most attractive person at this party would fall madly in love with me. (They do, and their "love" manifests as a violent, obsessive possessiveness. You can never leave their sight again.)

3. I wish I knew what my partner was really thinking. (You now hear every single fleeting, unfiltered thought they have—from their secret annoyance with the way you chew to their daydreams about strangers—eroding your love one petty thought at a time.)

4. I wish my crush would just ask me out. (They do, out of pity, after you suffer a humiliating and public accident.)

5. I wish to be irresistible to anyone I choose. (You can turn it on at will, but you forget how to turn it off. A simple trip to the grocery store becomes a dangerous mob scene.)

6. I wish my parents would finally be proud of me. (They are, after you heroically sacrifice your own life to save them from a disaster the paw arranged.)

7. I wish my estranged child would call me. (They do. It's their one phone call from prison after being arrested for a heinous crime.)

The Price of Power: Wishes for Fame, Fortune, and a Terrible Fallout

The Price of Power: Wishes for Fame, Fortune, and a Terrible Fallout

For those who wish for greatness, the paw teaches that the throne is also a cage.

1. I wish I was the most famous person on Earth. (You are. You've just been named Patient Zero of a global pandemic.)

2. I wish I was the President. (You are. Of the chess club at a local community college, and they're about to vote you out for embezzling funds for snacks.)

3. I wish I had the power of invisibility. (You can turn invisible, but so do your clothes. You are now a very cold, naked, and unseen presence.)

4. I wish my band would have a number one hit song. (Your song becomes a global hit, but it's adopted as the anthem for a violent, totalitarian political movement.)

5. I wish to be the richest person in the world. (A global economic collapse wipes out every other person's wealth, making you the richest by default. Your billions are now worthless in a world of barter and chaos.)

6. I wish I could stop time. (You can. But you are also frozen in place along with everything else, a conscious statue for eternity.)

7. I wish I was a brilliant inventor. (You invent a machine that could solve the world's energy crisis, but you're immediately assassinated by the oil lobby and your invention is buried forever.)

The "Selfless" Sacrifice: Altruistic Wishes with a Sinister Silver Lining

The "Selfless" Sacrifice: Altruistic Wishes with a Sinister Silver Lining

Even the noblest of wishes can be curdled by the paw's malevolent logic.

1. I wish for world peace. (It is achieved when aliens invade and enslave all of humanity. There is no more war between nations, only a unified, silent servitude.)

2. I wish to cure cancer. (The cure is discovered, but it's a rare orchid that only grows on a remote, protected island. The ensuing corporate wars to control it kill more people than cancer ever did.)

3. I wish for an end to world hunger. (A cheap, nutrient-rich fungus now grows everywhere. It's all anyone can eat, it's tasteless, and it has eradicated all other agriculture and cuisine from the planet.)

4. I wish for all the plastic in the ocean to disappear. (It vanishes, but so does everything it was attached to, including thousands of boats, buoys, and deep-sea research equipment, causing untold chaos.)

5. I wish I could take on the emotional pain of my grieving friend. (You do. You are now crippled by their immense grief, while they, feeling unnaturally numb and empty, drift away from you entirely.)

6. I wish for irrefutable proof of an afterlife. (The skies fill with the screaming, tortured visages of the damned, proving there is an afterlife, and it is an eternity of horror for everyone.)

7. I wish humanity would stop climate change. (It stops, because a sudden, devastating solar flare knocks civilization back to the stone age.)


### Make Your Wish Your Own

The true magic—and terror—of the Monkey's Paw lies in its personal nature. The best wishes are those tied to our own specific hopes, fears, and flaws. Use these examples as a jumping-off point. Think about what you truly desire and then imagine the most clever, cruel, and ironic way it could be fulfilled. Just be glad you don't have a real mummified paw in your hands. Or do you?